Update: Someone takes some responsibility! (read below).
Over the past few days I have found it very difficult to actually write anything for this site. This usually happens when I get too frustrated about something that totally distracts me.
We have been given the unfortunate opportunity this past week to see that POLITICS holds more weight in this society than the welfare of our fellow man. While bodies floated in the polluted waters that flooded New Orleans, many Democrats, Republicans rushed to their ideological corners of the political spectrum to “ready the arrows of accusation” to shoot them at key individuals based on their political stripe. It almost reminded me of one big paint ball game between the red team and the blue team.
I was raised up in a home where the one thing that was expected of me was to own up to my mistakes. Lying or making excuses was simply not accepted. Either I told the truth and owned up to my responsibility or paid the consequences. Today, I expect my kids to operate the same way. Unfortunately, my kids have this principal down a lot better than many of the politicians surrounding the Katrina aftermath. Nobody wants to admit any wrongdoing on their behalf, but everyone is willing to toss the criticism on someone else (if I hear one more time someone make the statement “I do not want to point any fingers ’cause its too early, but…”). I dunno, I guess I’m just one of those people that define a leader as someone who owns up to their responsibility regardless of the consequences. This is something that is dramatized in movies, but so few people are willing to take it on the chin.
Over the past week I have watched both Democrats and Republicans skip around tough questions from the media regarding flawed handling of the Katrina aftermath. On one hand Bush tells Michael Brown “…you’re doing a heck of a job”. The next week, under heavy criticism by both Democrats and Republicans, Brown is sent packing back to D.C. where he later “resigns” from his head post as FEMA director. Nobody in the Bush administration stands up to admit that Brown was in over his head from the beginning of this whole thing. Once again government makes a costly mistake, and once again it gets explained away. [Note: As I mentioned the other day, FEMA has a long history of late arrivals to natural disasters. The American people deserve a full explanation regarding this and so far we have not received it].
On the other hand you have Democrats who “circle the wagons” around both Governor Kathleen Blanco and Mayor Ray Nagin dispite their gross negligence for not following through on their own policies.
When all of this went down in New Orleans, the first questions that came to mind were: “How many people were hurt?” The other question popped up once I saw along with the rest of America that help was being delayed was “Who screwed up?” As a former manager in two IT departments for two major companies along with my experience as an entrepreneur, trying to figure out the political leanings of state and local officials would have been absurd. My years of training and experience simply tells me to seek out the “dead wood” and get rid of it. Although I realized that Nagin was under extreme circumstances, I also realized that he was the elected official in that city and he obviously screwed up to some degree (based on their own hurricane evacuation plan).
I expressed my “two cents” on Nagin online recently and was met with the assumption that my comments were simply based on the fact that he was a Democrat. Although I was very pissed off at this assumption , I also realized that we are living in a day that ANY intellectual discussion is watered down to a Democratic vs. Republican debate (even though I am not registered as either). I mentioned in my comments that while the finger pointing was heating up, I hoped that ALL involved parties would take the appropriate criticisms including Nagin.
Why are you singling out the brotha?
If Nagin was a white Republican with ties to either Bush and/or Haliburton, he would already have been labeled a racist a long time ago. Many in the black community would have been more than eager to point out that while blacks suffered in the streets, he and his white staff (if he and his staff were white) was nice and safe in one of the nicest hotels in town. I know of several people that would have been quick to ask the question “So is this what you call ‘compassionate’ conservatism?”
But because Nagin is a Democrat and black(In that order—He used to be a Republican until he realized he would loose his bid for mayor if he did not switch parties), many in the black community have been somewhat mum on his shortcomings during the Katrina aftermath pushing the brunt of the blame on Bush without being able to accurately articulate that assumption.
Just as many in the black community want to see white non-Democratic politicians own up to there responsibilities as elected officials, we should demand no less from those who align with our political leanings.
To his credit, Nagin has made a considerable effort to rid his city of the corruption that has plagued it for years. But this does not eliminate the fact that more could have been done under his immediate authority to evacuate more people from the city as well as to provide food and water for those who opted to stay in the Superdome. To gloss over this fact simply because of his political pursuesion (or to some, the color of his skin) is totally ridiculous.
Unfortunately Nagin is just one small part of a huge machine called government that failed to make the necessary changes to the levee system for decades. The politicians of yesteryear had the convenience and luxury to “pass the buck” to the next administrations. The “ball” of responsibility has fallen into the hands of Nagin, Blanco, Bush and all agencies in between. WE THE PEOPLE cannot allow them to pass the responsibility to another future administration if we truly wish to prevent something like this from happening again.
Update:Bush on Katrina response: ‘I take responsibility’ (Reuters)
President George W. Bush took responsibility on Tuesday for any failures in the federal government’s response to Hurricane Katrina that struck two weeks ago and acknowledged the storm exposed deficiencies at all levels of government four years after the Sept. 11 attacks. (more…)





Why does it take human-made or natural disasters to illuminate the fact that these people were suffering long before this hurricane developed?
John L.
‘A Living Hell for Black People’: Cornel West on Katrina
By Peter Ortiz
September 12, 2005
Cornel West wasted no time telling his young audience how Hurricane Katrina demonstrated further the modern-day plight of black Americans.
West gave his keynote address to a gathering of black youth and their Big Brother mentors in Newark, N.J., Saturday. The noted Princeton University professor, scholar and author delivered a powerful speech reminding black youth of the racial injustice Katrina’s destruction unmasked.
“Let’s be honest … that we live in one the bleakest movements in the history of black people in this nation,” West announced at Paul Robeson Student Center at Rutgers University. “Look at the Super Dome, a living hell for black people. It’s not a big move from the hull of the slave ship to the living hell of the Super Dome.”
The Big Brothers Big Sisters of Metro Newark–sponsored event sought to drive home the importance of male mentoring and empowerment. West touched on everything from the powerful legacy of black artists in shaping American music to the influence of black activists who forged the civil-rights movement for the benefit of all Americans. But he struck a chord when he attacked the lack of government action in the aftermath of Katrina and how it has shamed Americans into visually confronting the racial divide playing out on their television screens.
“What the mainstream media won’t say and what this gathering in part is about is that … black folk, poor folk in New Orleans were catching hell before the hurricane,” West said.
He chided “successful” black Americans, such as Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, for lacking the courage to stand up to an administration and president that has failed black Americans. He also praised hip-hop artist Kanye West for announcing during a benefit for Katrina victims aired on live television that “George Bush doesn’t care about black people.” White House condemnation of West’s statement matters little when the racial disparity uncovered by Katrina became apparent.
“[Kanye West] was right,” West said. “How can anyone conclude that the Bush administration has compassion for black people?”
So, it’s government, big bad government at fault. Yeah, right. It’s not govermnent. It’s incompetence. Clinton’s FEMA was quite competent. Neither Bush Sr or Bush Jr.’s FEMA was.
Only a federal government is in the position to coordinate something like Katrina relief. And Bush failed miserably. Again. Just like he failed to protect the country before 9/11. Just like he failed with everything he touches.
You aren’t condemning government. You are condemning incompetent fools. That is, you are condemening the Bush administration.
John,
West is basically a socialist (rich folk= bad, po’ folk= always innocent). Its amazing to me that Mr. Ortiz (the writer of the piece you posted) says NOTHING about who had been rowing that slave ship for over two decades. No need to further comment on someone who will pick and choose what facts they want to accept as truth. You dig?
tristero,
To believe that FEMA was competent under Clinton is to deny history itself. Did you not even take the time to read the article I linked to in the post? If you don’t like Bush than say it, but don’t spread a falsehood.
Duane-
You are really a lone voice in the wilderness. I consider myself on the left, and I agree with everything you say in this piece. No one in our government is willing to ask the hard questions and face difficults truths if it may implicate *their* side. The only policy on left or right is to blame the other side and ignore or gloss over their own mistakes. I’ve been reading left and right blogs through this whole disaster, and the selection of truths is astounding. Almost uniformly, the left blogs are silent on the responsibility Mayor Nagin had to his people, and the right rabidly defends every (mis)step by Bush, FEMA, etc.
Rational thinking for yourself seems to be dead in this country. Just line up on your side and read your talking points memo. No need to ask any questions….
It was all the stupid local politicians’ fault. They shoulda rounded up all them buses that ‘ventually got all fluded and wer sitting around two days before the storm, forced the poor people to evacuate by using the entire police force to roudn them up and sit them on buses, and ship them off to shelters in ….wait, that’s easier said than done. Shelters where? Were other cities just going to drop everything and set aside large sporting venues for evacuees? Was the red cross going to take a proactive approach and anticipate a big disaster and start setting up massive shelters? Then they shouda just called the national guard, ordered up lotsa troops and boats and helicopters (that they didn’t have) and had them waiting on the edges of towns and cities for the fallout. Wait, that IS the Feds’ job.
Ok, nevermind that. Maybe the stupid local politicians sholda just gone to washington and FORCED the cheney regime to give them money via FEMA and Army Corps of Engineers to fix the levees so that they’d withstand a larger hurricane. That woulda been too easy, tho. We all know that the mayor of new orleans is a rich democrat - who votes REPUBLICAN!!. He backed bush twice.
wait, maybe it IS the local politicians’ fault.
Duane, how have you been? I’ve been tied up doing month end financial reporting, so while I’ve checked daily to your blog, I’ve not had time to write.
On the subject of this whole Katrina-gate scandal I have a few questions to consider:
1. Where is the line drawn between others helping the poor, and being indicted as evil just because of the existence of a poor underclass?
2. Where is the transition of responsibility between society for creating a poor underclass, and a person exercising (or lack there of) certain behavior which keeps them poor?
3. How come Cornell West, Jessie Jackson, all of the members of the CBC, and Eric Michael Dyson are able to live the same lifestyle (Affluent) of the Black Republicans (Or white Republicans for that matter) they vilify?
4. What is the difference between the hull of a slave ship and the Katrina-Super Dome? I’ll help you…The slave ship was not optional, the Super Dome was (As far as the local authorities that could have made other accommodations are concerned)
5. Why are said Black leaders mute on the topics that exclude whites, i.e. out of wedlock births, black on black crime, gangsta/thug mentality within the culture, high illiteracy rates, etc
6. Why are we (Blacks) the default mascot for every liberal beef (except abortion and gay rights)?
7. Will the Black community ever again have independent thought apart from the Democratic Party?
8. Are social programs the only answer to Black poverty?
9. Why is the capitalist market in this country vilified, but the benefits (cash from profits in a free market) of the capitalist market (albeit directly) is what is used to help the poor?
10. From a political standpoint, how long will the Black community be the laughingstock in this country? We elect leaders (Blacks, Democrats, Black Democrats, etc) to positions of power. Then, we blame the closest Republican. In the case of Katrina, this means we bypass the mayor, the governor, and go straight to the White House.
11. What would have happened if Bush took control on Wednesday instead of Friday after the levee broke, and pushed aside a Democratic governor in activating a rescue/relief effort? Would blacks have said
a. “That Bush is on the scene. He really cares about Blacksâ€Â
b. “That @**hole Bush. He doesn’t care about us, he’s trying to grandstandâ€Â
c. “He’s trying to buy the Black voteâ€Â
12. What political choices do Blacks have other than the “sky is falling†petulant whining of the liberal left, and the “America is the center of God’s goodness†bland, picket fence euphoria of the conservative right?
13. When will the current debate on race include the Black middle class trying to move up the food chain, whiling bringing some fellow Blacks with them?
14. Do we (Blacks) really confuse political theater for reality, and conspiracy theories for truth?
15. Will we really figure out what the Black elite/ bougersie /elect want from society as a whole, and the Black community as a portion of the whole?
a. Does the Black community really require anything of itself or it’s political leaders/idols?
FEMA had problems with unqualified patronage appointments before, when the first President Bush was in office, badly botching the response to Andrew, see
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2005/0509.franklin.html
In response to a highly critical GAO report, Bill Clinton appointed James Lee Witt, who already had substantial experience with disaster management at the state level. Witt restructured FEMA in response to the GAO recommendations, and FEMA won praise in its handling of Hurricane Hugo and the Oklahoma City bombing. The second George Bush returned FEMA to its previous status as a sinecure for political cronies–and apparently to its old level of incompetence.
Heat wave in Chicago during the Clinton administration, mostly older, poor balck persons died.
Why was this not considered the result of racisim on Clintons part?
answer to question 11: b& c….
Politics stink (right and left)
noone is really “conservative” or “liberal”
People seemed to be motivated by their own self interest, except when it comes to taking responsibility .
ooops…responsibility ..that word exists only when it is to one’s advantage.